Expert Rating: 9.5 ( 3 Reviews )
9.3
David Arthur - Just Ride Bikes
Sep 26, 2023
The Trek Emonda is a fast and responsive race bike with a focus on aerodynamics and lightweight performance
9.3
Overall Rating
The Trek Emonda is a fast and responsive race bike with a focus on aerodynamics and lightweight performance
10
Weight
The Trek Emonda size 56 with a mid-range SRAM Force access groupset and deep section wheels weighs approximately 7.4 kilograms.
9.5
Aerodynamics
The Trek Amanda SLR is an aerodynamic race bike designed for professional riders to compete in tough races. The significant part of the aero claims on this bike comes from the one-piece carbon handlebar and stem found on the top-end models.
10
Pedaling Efficiency
The Trek Emonda offers good pedaling efficiency, but it's worth noting that the tires used on the bike may hold it back slightly. However, underneath the tire choice, you'll find a comfortable alloy road bike that delivers great overall performance. The bike's stiff frame contributes to efficient power transfer, making it responsive during sprints and climbs.
9.5
Design
The frame's design has evolved over the years, with a focus on aerodynamics. Notable design elements include the narrow head tube, deep fork blades, and shaped down tube.
7
Comfort
The bike doesn't offer the same level of comfort as other bikes in its category, and this lack of comfort can be noticeable when riding on cobbled roads.
10
Handling
The Trek Emonda is praised for its lively and punchy handling, making it highly responsive and encouraging riders to go fast. It offers a balanced H1.5 geometry for confident cornering.
9.6
Bike Radar
Sep 26, 2023
The Trek Emonda ALR 5 presents an intriguing proposition by challenging the conventional wisdom that carbon is the only choice for a high-performance road bike
9.6
Overall Rating
The Trek Emonda ALR 5 presents an intriguing proposition by challenging the conventional wisdom that carbon is the only choice for a high-performance road bike
10
Weight
The Trek Emonda ALR 5 model, made of hydroformed aluminum, weighs just over 9 kilograms (around 20 pounds), which is competitive for an aluminum road bike in this category.
9.5
Aerodynamics
The bike is equipped with aerodynamic features, including truncated aerodynamic tubing on the down tube and fork.
10
Pedaling Efficiency
The Trek Emonda ALR 5 offers a responsive and efficient pedaling experience. Despite being an aluminum frame, it provides a comfortable ride quality with smooth rear-end compliance. The aluminum frame of the Emonda ALR 5 is well-constructed and visually clean, with noticeable aerodynamic features like truncated aerofore tubing on the down tube and fork
10
Design
The Trek Emonda ALR 5 is introduced as a lightweight climbing bike that features a hydroformed aluminum frame paired with a carbon fork.
8
Comfort
The bike feels sluggish, despite concerns about comfort, the ride quality at the rear end is described as very smooth.
10
Handling
The Emonda ALR 5 features a geometry that strikes a balance between a racy and relaxed riding position. It's quick to respond to rider inputs and easy to maneuver, making it suitable for various riding styles.
9.7
Luis Scott
Sep 26, 2023
The Trek Emonda SL 6 model receives praise for its build quality, aerodynamic advantages, and sharp handling characteristics.
9.7
Overall Rating
The Trek Emonda SL 6 model receives praise for its build quality, aerodynamic advantages, and sharp handling characteristics.
9
Weight
Trek Emonda SL 6 model feels a bit heavy and suggests that it could benefit from shedding a few pounds to enhance its overall performance.
9.5
Aerodynamics
The bike's cornering characteristics, with quick steering and stable behavior, indirectly contribute to aerodynamic advantages during turns.
10
Pedaling Efficiency
The bike excels in drivetrain efficiency, especially during acceleration and high-speed riding. However, they prefer climbing out of the saddle due to the bike's weight. Trek Emonda has a very stiff bottom bracket and head tube area, which contributes to its performance and responsiveness.
9.5
Design
Trek's paint job with black and strategic elements of chameleon flip paint, making the bike visually appealing.
10
Comfort
The IsoSpeed coupler provides some comfort benefits, adjusting tire pressure and saddle selection plays a role in achieving comfort.
10
Handling
The Emonda has sharp and quick steering, making it agile when cornering. The bike feels stable and planted in corners, allowing riders to maintain their desired lines.
Sit back, relax, and let me deconstruct the marvel that is the Trek Emonda after analyzing three YouTube videos hosted by experts. The videos covered the bike’s componentry. The experts were impressed with the quality of the groupset, wheels, and finishing kit, which are all in line with the Emonda’s high-end positioning. These components complement the frame, ensuring that the bike performs exceptionally in a variety of settings, from steep ascents to high-speed sprints. Let me break it into understandable chunks for you.
Weight
Weight, a crucial factor in the world of cycling, is where we’ll begin. The Trek Emonda, in size 56, outfitted with a mid-range SRAM Force access groupset and deep section wheels, boasts a trim weight of approximately 7.4 kilograms. This puts it in the lightweight category, perfect for those who crave speed and efficiency on the road.
On the other hand, the Trek Emonda ALR 5 model, crafted from hydroformed aluminum, comes in just over 9 kilograms or around 20 pounds. While it might not match the featherweight status of carbon fiber counterparts, this weight is quite competitive for an aluminum road bike in its class.
Now, the Trek Emonda SL 6 model might feel a tad heavy to some riders, suggesting that it could benefit from shedding a few pounds to enhance its overall performance.
Aerodynamics
Aerodynamics plays a pivotal role in the Trek Emonda’s design, especially in the top-tier models like the Trek Amanda SLR. These are aerodynamic race bikes tailored for professional riders to excel in demanding races. The one-piece carbon handlebar and stem, featured on the top-end models, contribute significantly to its aero claims.
The bike is equipped with various aerodynamic features, including truncated aerodynamic tubing on the down tube and fork. These design elements work in harmony to reduce drag, allowing you to slice through the air with ease.
Surprisingly, the bike’s cornering characteristics also play a role in its aerodynamic advantages during turns. Its quick steering and stable behavior contribute indirectly to improved aerodynamics when navigating corners at high speeds.
Pedaling Efficiency/Frame Stiffness
Pedaling efficiency is at the core of the Trek Emonda’s performance. While the choice of tires may influence its efficiency, the bike’s underlying construction is designed to deliver a comfortable and efficient pedaling experience. The stiff frame ensures efficient power transfer, making it highly responsive during sprints and climbs.
The Trek Emonda ALR 5 model maintains this ethos of responsive and efficient pedaling. Despite being an aluminum frame, it provides a comfortable ride quality with smooth rear-end compliance. Notably, the aluminum frame features aerodynamic touches like truncated aerofor tubing on the down tube and fork.
In terms of drivetrain efficiency, the Emonda shines, especially during acceleration and high-speed riding. However, some riders may notice its weight during out-of-the-saddle climbs. The bike boasts a remarkably stiff bottom bracket and head tube area, contributing significantly to its overall performance and responsiveness.
Design
The Trek Emonda’s design has evolved over the years with a strong focus on aerodynamics. Notable design elements include the narrow head tube, deep fork blades, and shaped down tube, all of which contribute to its sleek and aerodynamic appearance.
The Emonda ALR 5 introduces itself as a lightweight climbing bike, featuring a hydroformed aluminum frame paired with a carbon fork. This combination aims to strike a balance between weight savings and performance.
Trek’s attention to detail extends to the bike’s paint job, featuring black and strategic elements of chameleon flip paint that add a touch of visual appeal to the overall package.
Comfort
Comfort, while not the bike’s primary focus, is not entirely overlooked. The Trek Emonda may not offer the same level of comfort as some other bikes in its category, and this may become noticeable when riding on cobbled roads or particularly rough terrain.
However, some riders describe the ride quality at the rear end as remarkably smooth, thanks in part to the IsoSpeed coupler. Fine-tuning comfort can also be achieved through adjustments like tire pressure and saddle selection.
Handling
The Trek Emonda earns praise for its lively and punchy handling, making it highly responsive and encouraging riders to push the limits of speed. It offers a balanced H1.5 geometry that instills confidence during cornering, ensuring you can attack corners with precision.
The Emonda ALR 5 features a versatile geometry that strikes a balance between a racy and relaxed riding position. This translates to quick responses to rider inputs and effortless maneuverability, catering to various riding styles and preferences.
When it comes to handling, the Emonda impresses with sharp and quick steering. It feels agile while cornering, and its stability allows riders to maintain their desired lines with ease.
Overall Notes
To wrap it all up, the Trek Emonda is a fast and responsive race bike that places a significant emphasis on aerodynamics and lightweight performance. It’s designed for those who seek the thrill of speed and efficiency on the road.
In a surprising twist, the Trek Emonda ALR 5 model challenges the conventional wisdom that carbon is the only choice for a high-performance road bike. Crafted from hydroformed aluminum and complemented by a carbon fork, it offers a compelling proposition for riders looking for a mix of affordability and performance.
The Trek Emonda SL 6 model receives accolades for its build quality, aerodynamic advantages, and sharp handling characteristics. It’s a bike that’s poised to deliver a thrilling riding experience.
Curious to see how the Trek Emonda bike compares to others? Explore our comprehensive guides for an in-depth analysis of top-quality bicycles designed to meet various cycling requirements and preferences. Inside these guides, you’ll encounter a diverse array of excellent options tailored to your liking, along with helpful resources to support you in making a well-informed decision.
Your review of the Trek Emonda can benefit fellow cyclists. Share your insights with us.
John